Tilting at windmills

PNWPhotos.com a friendly and growing community of photographers with an interest in the Pacific Northwest region. We feature a Photography Discussion Forum and Pacific Northwest Photo Gallery. It's a fun and friendly place to talk with other photographers, ask questions, share you knowledge, view and post photos and more!


BobH

Administrator
Staff member
Electric Turbine Windmills are common in certain parts of the Pacific Northwest. They're huge and impressive in person. It's tricky to capture the feeling on film, especially the motion.

Here's a normal photo of them windmills. If you're not familiar with them, it doesn't do a good job of conveying how they work. All in all, it's fairly bland.

DSC_4707-Edit.JPG
 
Last edited:
I wanted to show the motion of the blades.

Should be simple enough, right? Just add some motion blur, and make it look like an airplane propellor!

Pop on an ND filter and do a long exposure, this won't take long...

DSC_4693.JPG


Cool, a field full of fancy sticks with a bit of blur on the end!

Well, that didn't work quite like I intended... So why not? The blades are moving slowly, and they're thin. So most of the time the blade isn't in the way of the background. The small bit of white it adds simply isn't enough to be clearly visible. or even visible at all for that matter.

The only setting that really matters here was exposure time, and it was 10 seconds.
 
Last edited:
I decided to try a "short long exposure" Isn't that an oxymoron? Well, yeah, but what I mean is that it's a lot shorter than 10 seconds, but it's still longer than what you would normally shoot. In this case, it was 1/2 second.

DSC_4700.JPG


This is better, and it does give a feel for the motion. I think with a better (darker) background, this would work.
 
Last edited:
Plan B...

This is a technique that I read about someplace, can't recall exactly where. It uses the in camera multiple exposure function. I have never used it before, and I may have to experiment with it some more.

DSC_4686-Edit.JPG
DSC_4722-Edit.JPG




I think the resulting photo is cool, and if you're familiar with the windmills, you may enjoy it.

But it doesn't really imply motion, and if you've never seen one, you might just think they had lots of blades.
 
Last edited:
This is a cool technique. You would almost think they are like electric flowers. I do prefer the "short long" exposure for motion. Great stuff.
 
Bob, this is a cool idea! I agree with Arline that the "short-long" exposure seems best.

It occurs to me that this cries out for something like a second curtain flash technique which would provide you with a streak of moving blades coming up to a sharp blade at the end. I didn't explain that well, but maybe it will make sense… Now I fully realize that you can't do a flash on something like this, but would there be a way to use that principle for a double exposure?
 
Bob, this is a cool idea! I agree with Arline that the "short-long" exposure seems best.

It occurs to me that this cries out for something like a second curtain flash technique which would provide you with a streak of moving blades coming up to a sharp blade at the end. I didn't explain that well, but maybe it will make sense… Now I fully realize that you can't do a flash on something like this, but would there be a way to use that principle for a double exposure?

Mike, a second curtain flash would give me exactly what I need. As you suggest, it's not possible for something this large, at least without extreme measures.

Double exposure? Could work, if you could line the blades up with luck or skill.
 
Double exposure? Could work, if you could line the blades up with luck or skill.

I can envision that it would be a post processing thing. Take a few short-long exposure shots and a few normal exposure shots and blend the two best in post. Tripod is essential, of course, but you're likely on a tripod already. You'd have something pretty cool, I think.
 
Last edited:
Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)



PNWPhotos.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com

Back
Top